How do we understand worker silence despite poor conditions - as the actress said to the woman bishop

Date

2017-05-12

Advisors

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Sage Publications

Type

Article

Peer reviewed

Yes

Abstract

This article considers the customary choice of silence over voice of two groups of UK workers, women clergy and women actors, who routinely tolerate poor quality conditions rather than express dissatisfaction. We argue that a key mediating factor is an expanded version of Hirschman’s (1970) concept of loyalty. The article considers how occupational ideologies facilitate loyalty as adaptation to disadvantage in ways that discourage voice, in framing silence as positive. Consequently, we also identify this type of loyalty as potentially salient in understanding silence in other occupations. A descriptive model comparing strength of occupational ideology and voicing of dissatisfaction is outlined and through discussion of findings the article offers conceptual refinements of loyalty in accounting for worker silence.

Description

Susanna Wesley Foundation, Roehampton University

Keywords

Calling, clergy, loyalty, occupational ideologies, silence, voice, women worker–actors

Citation

Dean, D. and Greene, A.M. (2017) How do we understand worker silence despite poor conditions - as the actress said to the woman bishop. Human Relations, 70 (10), pp. 1237-1257

Rights

Research Institute